Husband refuses to complete Form E? What the court rules say
Before anyone applies to court
Form E is the financial statement used in court proceedings for a financial order. GOV.UK says that when you ask the court to decide, you and your ex-partner need to fill in Form E (GOV.UK). Before an application is made, the court rules don't require either of you to fill it in.
The pre-application protocol annexed to Practice Direction 9A does deal with that stage. It says the court will usually expect the parties to have provided full disclosure to each other, including appropriate financial disclosure, and that if parties give pre-application financial disclosure, it must be full and honest (PD 9A, protocol paragraphs 6 and 32). Paragraph 3.4 of the practice direction says any breach of it or of the protocol will be taken into account when the court decides whether to depart from the general rule on costs.
If you can't agree, GOV.UK says you can apply for the court to decide, using Form A (GOV.UK). Whether and when to do that is a decision about your own case, and it's one to talk through with a solicitor, a family mediator or the free help listed at the end of this page.
Our guide to divorce financial disclosure sets out what the rules and forms say at each stage.
The rule once proceedings have started
When an application for a financial order is issued, the court fixes a first appointment not less than 12 and not more than 16 weeks after the application is filed, unless the fast-track procedure in Chapter 5 of Part 9 applies (FPR 9.12(1)). Then:
- Both parties must exchange their financial statements with each other, and file them with the court, at the same time, not less than 35 days before the first appointment (FPR 9.14(1)). The rule applies to each party, so it covers whoever applied and whoever is responding.
- Each statement must be verified by a statement of truth and come with the documents the form asks for (FPR 9.14(2)).
- A party who was unavoidably prevented from sending a document with the form must serve and file it at the earliest opportunity, with a written explanation of the failure to send it (FPR 9.14(3)).
- Between the filing of the application and the first appointment, no other disclosure or inspection of documents may be requested or given, apart from the documents that come with the financial statements and a few listed exceptions (FPR 9.14(4)).
Our Form E guide explains how the 35 days are counted, and the free deadline calculator works out the dates from your first appointment.
What the rules say about costs
The general rule in financial remedy proceedings is that the court won't order one party to pay the other's costs (FPR 28.3(5)). The court can make a costs order where it considers it appropriate because of a party's conduct in relation to the proceedings, before or during them (FPR 28.3(6)). In deciding whether to, it must have regard to a list of things, which includes any failure to comply with the rules, any order of the court or any relevant practice direction (FPR 28.3(7)).
Two other sources point at Form E directly:
- The Form E notes for guidance say the court might make an order for costs against you if you don't follow the deadlines for filing Form E (Form E notes).
- When considering a costs order, the court must have particular regard to how far each party has complied with the requirement to send documents with the financial statement, and the explanation given for any failure to comply (FPR 9.15(6)).
The rules say what the court must consider. They don't say what it will decide in any one case, and we don't either.
The court's general case management powers
Part 4 of the Family Procedure Rules gives the court general powers to manage a case. Among them, the court can extend or shorten the time for complying with any rule, practice direction or order, adjourn or bring forward a hearing, require a party to attend court, and take any other step or make any other order to manage the case (FPR 4.1(3)).
When the court makes an order, it can make it subject to conditions and specify the consequence of failing to comply with it (FPR 4.1(4)). Where a party fails to comply with a rule, practice direction or order, any sanction it imposes for that failure has effect unless the party in default applies for and obtains relief from it (FPR 4.5). In deciding an application for relief, the court considers all the circumstances, including whether the application was made promptly and whether the failure was intentional (FPR 4.6(1)).
At the first appointment
The first appointment must be conducted with the objective of defining the issues and saving costs (FPR 9.15(1)). The court decides how far the questionnaires must be answered and which documents must be produced, and gives directions about any further documents (FPR 9.15(2)). Both parties must attend in person unless the court directs otherwise (FPR 9.15(8)).
Not less than 14 days before the first appointment, each party files and serves a concise statement of the issues, a chronology, a questionnaire setting out the further information and documents they ask for, and a notice saying whether the first appointment can be used as an FDR appointment (FPR 9.14(5)). The rules say the questionnaire is set out by reference to the concise statement of issues. They don't set out a separate procedure for when the other party's financial statement hasn't arrived, so how to handle that in your own case is a question for a solicitor.
Keeping your own records in order
Whatever the other side does, the rules on your own Form E still apply to you: the deadline, the statement of truth and the documents. It can also help to keep a dated note of what was sent, received or asked for and when, with copies, so the facts are easy to find if the court asks. The Form E example shows what a complete form looks like with every section filled in.
The Form E Organiser follows the form section by section, adds up totals A to L, works out your deadline and has 7 request letters ready to send.
Common questions
What happens if my ex doesn't send their Form E?
The rules require both parties to exchange and file Form E not less than 35 days before the first appointment (FPR 9.14(1)). Failing to comply with the rules is one of the things the court must consider when deciding whether to make a costs order (FPR 28.3(7)), and the court has general powers to make orders and set the consequence of not complying (FPR 4.1(4)). What it does in a particular case is for the judge.
Is Form E compulsory?
In court proceedings for a financial order, yes: FPR 9.14(1) says both parties must exchange and file it. Before an application is made, the rules don't require Form E, though the pre-application protocol says the court will usually expect full disclosure (PD 9A).
Can I still file my Form E if my ex hasn't done theirs?
The rule is that both parties exchange and file at the same time. It doesn't say what to do when only one is ready. That's a question about your own case for a solicitor, or the free help on GOV.UK and Advicenow.
Can a judge order someone to complete Form E?
The court can make orders to manage a case and can specify the consequence of failing to comply with them (FPR 4.1(3) and (4)). The rules don't promise any particular order. The judge decides what is needed.
Related guides
- Form E: the divorce financial statement, explained
- Form E divorce example: a completed financial statement
- Form E deadline calculator
Sources
- Family Procedure Rules, Part 9 (rules 9.12, 9.14, 9.15)
- Family Procedure Rules, Part 28 (rule 28.3)
- Family Procedure Rules, Part 4 (rules 4.1, 4.5, 4.6)
- Practice Direction 9A and its pre-application protocol
- Form E notes for guidance 01.23 (GOV.UK)
- Get the court to decide (GOV.UK)
Free help: GOV.UK, Advicenow, or a solicitor or family mediator for advice about your own case.